Another Week, Another Song and Dance
Having spent most of this past week suffering through a not-so-fun bout with a very resilient cold, I’ve been fortunate enough to have been able to spend a fair amount of time listening to some new music, as well as a few old favorites. Since class discussion sort of revolved around covering other music that was being made around the same time as the stuff we’ve already studied, I figure now is the perfect time to go off on a bit of a tangent myself.
“You’ve Done It Again, Virginia” by the National is, simply, a stunning song. A rarity for the band, the song is a low-fi minimalist work, completely acoustic and at times almost indecipherable for the listener. However, the lyrics are just as potent as any of the band’s more lively tracks, making me wonder if the purpose of this B-Side was to challenge the listener to actually start paying attention to more than the simple beats and guitar licks of their singles. Like several of the band’s other works, the song can be downright chilling in its depiction of scenery. The first verse alone sets a haunting, somber tone:
You went in and put a record on
To make it sound like someone was home
And thanked yourself for pouring yourself a drink
As a fan of the band, I was delighted to stumble upon a crucial missing piece to my catalog in this song. The lyrics may be piercing and even depressing to read as text on a screen, but like everything else with this group, the sum is so much more than the parts.
On a wholly unrelated note, I also, at the bequest of a friend, listened to the new Keane album. For the uninitiated, Keane is a Brit Pop trio that is now on their third attempt to become a band that is more than just a me-too Coldplay clone. Their first CD, Hopes and Fears, was a solid collection of piano ballads and pop-friendly Coldplay soundalikes. But then the group decided that being called a poor-Brit’s Coldplay wasn’t good enough for them, and so they changed up their sound with bigger production, sweeping melodies, and some darker material to sing about for their 2006 release, Under the Iron Sea. Unfortunately, Coldplay did almost all of the same things on X and Y, so the plan didn’t really work that well. But, hey, at least they got some air time on HBO’s second season of Entourage.
This time around, Keane are really, really serious about making you notice them. The CD, which is a mixed bag of fantastic tunes and some head-slappingly bad lyrics, is best described in one word: “Spiraling.” It’s the name of the first song on the CD, which is also the band’s current single. As a song, it’s like some sort of ’80s throwback, channeling a bit of Prince‘s funk and handful of other terrible tragedies that our country was forced to suffer during that time. Electronic drum kits are, thankfully, absent.
The rest of the CD is all ups and downs. Perfect Symmetry, the album’s name, is also the name of the best track of the whole bunch. But for almost every good track, there’s a misfire. And with only 11 tracks to be had, the whole thing comes across as a bit uneven. Definitely a CD that will be benefited by the iTunes era of music, but still disappointing for a band that has tried for 5 years to truly shake the establishment and demand that the masses stand up and take notice of them. There’s potential in this CD to get the group some new followers, but the rather retro, “been-there, heard-that” sound that the CD carries comes at a time when so many acts are pushing music in exciting new directions. How many people are ready to go back and start spelunking around the past?
In many ways the CD is a strong contrast to TV on the Radio‘s Dear Science. While that group is also taking past styles and exploiting them in new ways, they do so in a far more dynamic, abstract way. And, hopefully, I’ll be able to talk about that more next week.